Is this an age old debate or a struggle for most? Personally, I have been back and forth with this for a while now. Recently, I was in the market for a new pack, and I had been eyeing a very traditional looking pack with a fairly high dollar value and described as an “heirloom” quality pack. I still have a desire to own this pack for sure, I have researched it, asked about it, had friends who own that brand attest to how well made their packs are. I also have friends who attest to the quality and functionality of a newer style pack and how well it performs. Both have great reviews and fanfare, so I know either would be a great purchase. So now is it about price point, or durability, or functionality, or customization? It’s just a back pack, how hard could this be.
Well we’re gear junkies, we have to dissect the type of fabrics and stitching, so we’re looking at every facet to poke holes in our decisions!
To be honest, what it came down to for me was functionality. A more modern pack is a little more customizable, a little more modular. It wasn’t about cost (I’m always looking to not spend so much), or look, or even brand. It truly became about what was best to suit my needs for a “buy once, cry once” type of purchase, to allow me to have what I consider the four season pack for me.
I started thinking about this, and realized I struggle with this for most of my purchases for gear and equipment. Is this knife traditional looking enough for me, am I looking for an optic or how well it’s made? Does it hold an edge, is it durable, or is it the next catch all tool? Sometimes we go down the rabbit hole of ridiculousness. Does this rifle have the look I want, does that even matter so long as it shoots true? Crazy thoughts sometimes. The first rule of being cool is looking cool right?
I think the look of things appeals to us, a lot of us strive to learn the old ways, but does that mean we have to carry traditional only? Does it make your experiences in camp any better or worse if you use a oilskin trap, and use an air mattress to save your back? I think the old timers would have loved some modern comforts they were not privileged to have, like instant flame. Just some thoughts...how do you feel about Traditional vs. Modern?


